I'll write more about my weekend dans le Noorrddd tomorrow, but today I want to bring up "le 1er mars - La journée sans immigrés", or "March 1st - The day without immigrants", with the idea being that for 24 hours, all immigrants would stop buying and working to show the impact that they really have on the French economy. March 1st was chosen because it was the day that the "immigration choisie" (controlled immigration) law took effect back in 2005. Similar events will also be held in Spain, Italy and Greece.
I haven't quite decided if I'm going to participate today or not, but I do think the idea is interesting - and well-timed, given all the national debates going around about "What it means to be French". I also think it's easy for most of us to forget how tough it can be for immigrants in France. We all complain about having to go to the préfecture, dealing with red tape, etc, but given our nationalities, we actually have it quite easy when compared to many other foreigners.
If you want to learn more about the event, you can click here for the main website.
I meant to blog about this a week or so ago, but completely forgot.
A French website called "Mailorama" announced a few weeks ago that it was planning on renting a few double-decker busses and then driving them around Paris on November 14, throwing out bags of money worth several thousand euros, in an effort to promote their site. They assured the public that a few security guards had been hired to maintain order. When the Préfecture of Paris got wind of this, they immediately became concerned and put the stop down. After much negotiation, it was decided that Mailorama would be allowed to distribute the money at one location near the Eiffel Tower.
Word got out, and people - to the tune of 5,000 - flooded in from the nearby suburbs. It was not the crowd of Parisian yuppies that Mailorama had been hoping to target - instead, it was mainly unemployed young men who were ready to fight for those bags of money. The préfecture decided to cancel the event for security reasons, and out of frustration, some of the crowd began throwing apples and oranges around, while others took their anger out on local cars and/or stores.
Mailorama has now said that they will give roughly 100,000€ to the "Secours Populaire". And while the event was a complete failure, I guess it's done what they hoped to acoomplish- ie. get people talking about them....
On the way back from the 20th Anniversary celebration of the Abbey Bookshop last night, I came across this:For the non-French speakers, the sign roughly says "This building has sat empty since 2004, and has been taken over by 10 students (blah blah can't read it) in precarious situations. Le CROUS is asking us for 3000€ per month and per occupant, and has obtained an order for our expulsion."
It immediately reminded me of a few different shows I've seen on TV here, covering the housing crisis and the insanely high number of empty buildings in Paris. A lot of companies (both French & foreign) apparently buy up these big apartment buildings left and right as a way to sort of hide their money - and then they just leave them empty. The French government also owns a good chunk of them.
Meanwhile, there is a major housing crisis in Paris and tons of students and/or people with low-incomes who can't find a place to live. Some students have thus started requisitioning these buildings - basically taking them over and using them as their own. In one report I saw, each of the students had a floor of their own - roughly 100m2 - filled with crown molding and marble fireplaces. Of course the building was completely empty, so most of them only had a mattress, some clothes and maybe some books in their entire apartment. And they had to live with the fear that they could be kicked out at any moment, or could come home and find the doors locked with all of their things inside.
Having spent quite a bit of time looking for an apartment in Paris, I know how frustrating (and soul-sucking) it can be, especially for those who don't have someone who can sign as a guarantor for them. And I do think it's absolutely crazy that all of these buildings sit empty - but they tend to be in the chicest neighborhoods of Paris and of course the residents there don't want to live with rowdy students or low-income people.
I did not leave the house at all Monday. I'd planned on it - I'd wanted to check out the last of the soldes and then head over to Aimee's café to say hello. But Metéo France's dire predictions of rain and gale-force winds kept me inside. I was only slightly bitter that night when I realized that their forecasts were several hours off and the wind didn't really pick up until around midnight.
So I thought to myself "Well, that's okay, you can go out Tuesday instead." Unfortunately what I did not know was that there was a huge student protest scheduled for Tuesday afternoon. I ran into my building's concierge in the hallway, and he told me it was expected to be a violent one. They'd removed all the cars from the streets and some of the small stores had even decided to close up shop for the afternoon. I still had plans to go out and profite of the last day of the soldes, but my plans were foiled again when I got downstairs. The were hoards of policemen on the streets and they weren't letting anyone in or out of the residential buildings. So back upstairs I went, to watch all the fuss from my window:The whole thing seemed rather peaceful to me - but then again, I guess it's better to err on the side of caution, you know how these things can turn on a dime. Just look at Leesa's experience with a much smaller student manif that took place a week ago. It seemed fine to me as they went by my place but it had practically turned into a riot just a few blocks later.
Here's a short video I took - you'll notice at the end of the video that the crowd goes up the street as far as the eye can see (grr, Blogger wouldn't upload the video, so I had to upload it to YouTube instead and lost some of the image quality in the process):
And I'm not really sure what the point of this thing is, but I had to laugh at the dude carrying the Breton flag. You'll always see a few of them at any manif, no matter what the protest is about.This is one of the biggest protests I've seen in front of my place though - the people just kept coming and coming, for a good solid two hours.The whole thing was followed up by a bunch of police vans:and then of course bringing up the rear were the street cleaners. They do a good job, ten minutes after it ended, you'd have never known a massive protest had just taken place.
Oof. Yesterday I had one of those hang-overs that just kept getting worse as the day went on. "Rhum-rhum revenge", to quote Doc.
I went out yesterday around noon, and only had one thing on my mind - going back to bed! But on the way back, I discovered that the Gay Pride parade was taking place on my frickin' street, so no buses were running. Looking at the masses of people moving toward me, I felt defeated, like "No way am I going to have the energy to fight through this crowd and get home". But I eventually sucked it up and pushed my way through the endless sea of people, even getting caught up in the energy a bit along the way: Until I realized "Wait a minute, how the hell am I going to nap with all this noise??"
By the time it was time to go to The Abbey Bookshop for Ian's book party, I was feeling pretty shitty (and I don't think I was the only one, lol). "Hair of the dog" was mentioned, so I took a glass of red that was offered to me. Probably wasn't the best idea. Looking at all the rustic cheeses & meats Ian had brought wasn't helping either. So needless to say, I made it home at a fairly decent hour, sober as a judge. But at least I had a new book to read.
The aftermath of the Gay Pride parade - good luck street sweepers!
And now I'm returning to bed.
24h sans nous
I remember something like this in LA. There were huge rallies. All the cleaning staff at USC came in earlier than usual, did their work, and then left for the rally.
Let's see how this one goes. Will keep an eye on the news.
I'm not sure I agree with this in theory. ALL countries have immigrants and everyone in every country has difficult stuff to deal with. A 24 hour protest wont change anything and sometimes you just have to suck it up and say "if I choose to live in another country, I choose to deal with all the positive and negatives". I went to work today because I have professional responsibilities to maintaine, immigrant or not. France didnt ask me to come here and work, so I'm not going to take the day off just because I'm an immigrant!
Gee, you mean people would have to proofread their own emails in English at my work?!
@Crystal - I don't think you really understand what is being suggested. If you were one of the minorities living on the outskirts of the city, you would be all too anxious to join in with a bit of solidarity.
There are certainly many problems with the way immigrants are treated in France, in particular the attitudes towards non-white immigrants, and it's a problem that absolutely needs to be dealt with. I wonder though if taking 24 hours off of work and shopping is the most effective way to protest these problems. If the stereotype of immigrants from Africa and the Middle East is that they come to France to suck social services out of the state and don't work, doesn't taking a day off of work just give the FN a reason to say "see what we mean?" A more effective campaign might be TV commercials highlighting the many, many immigrants who work hard and contribute to society, or motivated, educated people who can't get work based on their names or how they look. Force the French to reexamine their stereotypes and prejudices in the face of direct contadictions.
it sounds like a rad idea to me. working immigrants 'cotisent' and when they buy things they pay the TVA like everyone does. if you want to show the government that immigrants have been a boost for the French economy and contributing members of society what better way than through their euros?
There's no bad publicity
ahhh, i wonder how it had ended. I'd heard that it was going to happen and we mused over the choas that would be caused. Guess we weren't wrong!
How did their marketing department think that was a good idea?! Especially with all the warnings from the Préfecture...
Somebody once said, "There's no such thing as bad publicity. You only need to worry when no one is talking about you."
gee...what an unpredictable outcome...not.
I can't even imagine the most naive fresh out of college marketing majors coming up with this idea?
Whoa!! That's trippy because I was picturing that as I was reading it... At least they gave some money to a good cause, in the end...
No, no, we won't go
when we moved out of my FIL's apartment into the place we bought, I told my FIL that I had friends who would rent our place in a heartbeat if he was looking for a renter. He told me no way would he rent because there was zero incentive for owners. First of all, the rent he earned would be taxed at 50%. Then he would have to pay for renters insurance and for any problems/repairs that came up while it was occupied. The money that he would earn from a one bed apartment would in no way pay for all the hassle of renting it out. And that is if things went well. If the renter decided to not pay rent, it could take between 2 and 5 years to get him out, so no rent during that period PLUS the cost of a lawyer and a court case. When you hear it explained like that, you wonder why anyone would bother renting their place. He ended up leaving it empty until he sold the apartment.
Just another example of how illogical, and sometimes heartless, the French can be.
Ditto what Nicole said.
The French aren't any more or less illogical or heartless than anybody else---French law however is often dim-witted at best.
We considered renting instead of selling our old apartment, but the rent and tax laws are totally against the owners. So we just sold it.
Blame Sarko?
I saw that building a few weeks ago. Broke my heart a little bit, because I know just as well as you do what a pain it can be to find a decent, affordable place in Paris.
One empty building I know about that drives me crazy is the Piscine Molitor in the 16th - it's an enormous public pool that has been unused for 10 years or so. It's classified as a national monument but would cost too much to renovate, so it just SITS there. In the most expensive neighborhood in the city. ugh!
i almost took a picture of the same thing after the abbey bookshop thing. it's so frustrating, like you said, because housing is at such a premium!
oh yes the joy of France's demonstration! I never took part in any of those, because even if I had some interests, there are always people to get into trouble and mess up with would lead to a riot and the Gendarmerie intervention, some people get hurt or taken by the police... The thing is, demonstrate to show ones disagreement ok but it always disrupt the bus and car traffic, but also as you just wrote, pedestrians according to where you live!
Oh, the excitement I miss out on not living in Paris. C'est triste.
one of the perks of living in paris i guess...free entertainment right outside your window!
P.S. you wrote "France's dire predictions..." and I read it like 4 times saying "dire" like "deer" in french not understanding the sentence til i realized it was "dire" as in "die-er"...my poor little franglais brain.
OOOPS! Hey, as I was reading this, I totally was thinking of my incident and then read further where you linked to it... So, it's probably better that you stayed put... I think the police LOVE spraying tear gas.. Seriously... since I've been here, I've be hit with tear gas 3 times and one was just outside the public restrooms at Velizy mall... So, go figure!!! I've NEVER experienced tear gas in the U.S.!! Anyhow... Sorry you missed Aimee's on Monday... Dawn and I were there for a few hours- from about noon to around 3 pm or so..... Too bad... It wasn't really that windy but it was wet and gloomy.. Take care, Leese
I have a fondness for the street cleaners... Once a place I was staying at flooded, and I left really early in the morning with as much as my things as I could. There were no taxi's and I spoke basically no French. But one of the street cleaners figured out that I wanted a cab and called one for me! I was so grateful. It was a awful, wet, rainy, gloomy morning.
Crystal- I know all about the franglais brain. Sometimes I don't know what language I speak...
We were there. We didn't see you.
Maybe that photo in your upper post has something to do with the photo in this post with the Hopital?... It was as you said near your place..